GBA Logo horizontal- lakesideca.info Facebook- lakesideca.info LinkedIn- lakesideca.info Email- lakesideca.info Pinterest- lakesideca.info Twitter- lakesideca.info Instagram- lakesideca.info YouTube Icon- lakesideca.info Navigation Search Icon- lakesideca.info Main Search Icon- lakesideca.info Video Play Icon- lakesideca.info Audio Play Icon- lakesideca.info Headphones Icon- lakesideca.info Plus Icon- lakesideca.info Minus Icon- lakesideca.info Check Icon- lakesideca.info Print Icon- lakesideca.info Picture icon- lakesideca.info Single Arrow Icon- lakesideca.info Double Arrow Icon- lakesideca.info Hamburger Icon- lakesideca.info TV Icon- lakesideca.info Close Icon- lakesideca.info Sorted- lakesideca.info Hamburger/Search Icon- lakesideca.info
Guest Blogs

E-Waste: Taming a Global Problem

We know the wrong way to deal with it. But what should we do instead?

A pile of laptop housings in Guiyu, China. (Photo: Basel Action Network / CC BY-ND / Flickr)

Rajesh was just 10 years old when we met. His days were spent standing on tiptoe to dunk computer circuit boards into big vats of hot acid. He had gloves but no goggles, and the acid splashed his shirt. He had an incessant cough and drank alcohol at night to ward off dizziness caused by the fumes.

Rajesh had moved with his older brother from the Indian countryside to work in , a suburb of the Indian capital New Delhi, which has become a charnel house of the digital world. The vats of acid that he tended removed the copper from the circuit boards so it could then be sold to a nearby factory that made copper wire. Somebody made a profit. But in the acrid air and with local well water , Rajesh’s future looked bleak.

This scene in Mandoli is a disturbing face of a vast global business in recycling electronic waste. Between (22 and 55 million tons) of used computers, TVs, air conditioners, mobile phones, refrigerators, light bulbs, and is produced every year around the world. All of it has to go somewhere, and all of it contains valuable metals — including toxic lead, cadmium, and mercury — that are worth reclaiming for future use.

Right now the “urban mining” of precious metals from is largely an environmental and social nightmare, polluting landscapes and poisoning its practitioners.

But it needn’t be like this.

Contrast Mandoli with the scene at Skellefteå, a neat Swedish gold-mining town close to the Arctic Circle with a famous hockey team. Here a giant industrial smelter , one of the world’s largest e-waste recycling companies, last year smelted (88,000 tons) of scrap e-waste, much of it circuit boards cut from European computers and mobile phones, to extract copper, gold, silver, and other precious metals. No vats of acid; no acrid fumes; no 10-year-old workers.

The automated process operates to European environmental and health and safety standards. It is equipped with systems to clean process gases and prevent dust releases. Waste heat generated during smelting is circulated to heat local buildings; and the scant leftovers from smelting are buried in purpose-build stores under the site.

Could this bode a better future for e-waste? Perhaps. Mainstream metals refining companies are now sniffing profits from e-waste and touting for business from the U.S. to China.

China’s mixed bag

Umicore in Hoboken, Belgium, a longstanding European metals refiner, is getting more of its raw materials from e-waste. The company’s director of European Union government affairs, Christian Hagelüken, says that its smelters can extract 400 grams (14 ounces) of gold from a metric ton (1.1 tons) of mobile phones, along with copper, silver, lead, tin, and indium. After smelting, the metals in the waste stream are chemically separated. The plastic casings go into the smelter, where they are burned to provide most of the fuel for the facility.

“Over 95% of the feed is turned into useful products,” Hageluken says. The final 5% includes toxic elements like mercury and cadmium that have to be disposed of “in a safe way,” plus slag that is used for constructing flood-protection dikes along the Belgian coast.

Such advanced processing plants are also turning up in the developing world. China in particular is keen to replace its notorious e-waste villages with high-tech e-waste metals recovery. Its flagship company, , says on its website that it aims

Not every Chinese company is so fastidious as GEM claims to be, however. When Thai police east of Bangkok in May this year, they found illegal workers burning waste in the open and spewing dioxin from plastics into the air. The surreptitious site by the Basel Action Network (BAN), a non-governmental organization that researches international trade in waste, using tracking devices attached to e-waste.

U.S. initiatives

In the United States, most e-waste is landfilled. A five years ago paid for by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency estimated that 8.5% of collected e-waste was exported, with Mexico, Venezuela, Paraguay, and China among the most popular destinations.

Some of that trade is legitimate. California-based collects hundreds of thousands of tons of e-waste a year across the U.S., which it shreds and sells either to its in Massena, New York, or to , an established copper-smelting giant in South Korea.

But the BAN has accused several American companies of “scam recycling” — that is, advertising recycling services that simply export to places such as Pakistan and the Philippines where the waste is “smashed, burned or treated with dangerous chemicals” by migrant workers.

Some electronics manufacturers are taking the initiative to improve practice, however. has been collecting old equipment for a decade to pass on to recyclers for the extraction of precious metals. Apple recently rolled out a robot able to dismantle iPhones, sorting components for ease of recycling “so we can recover materials that traditional recyclers can’t,” according to the company’s .

The company claims to recover aluminum, cobalt, copper, tungsten, tin, silver, tantalum, gold, palladium, and various rare earths. It intends to install the robot, known as Daisy, in many consumer countries, with the eventual aim of using only recycled materials in its production processes.

Good business

E-waste recycling is about more than good housekeeping. What is really driving the industry is the discovery that, in a world where the prices of metals are rising and most conventional mines are in distant countries with poor-grade ores, urban mining of e-waste is good business.

Copper and gold, which make up more than half the value in e-waste, are now often cheaper to obtain from jettisoned products, says Xianlai Zeng, an associate professor of solid waste management at Tsinghua University in Bejing, China. “Urban mining of e-waste is becoming more cost-effective than virgin mining,” he concluded in a , after studying the economics of eight recycling plants in the country.

This is not so surprising. There is more gold in a ton of mobile phones than in a ton of ore from a gold mine. One estimate is that all the e-waste discarded annually around the world .

Zeng’s analysis concluded that, with some government subsidies, urban mining in China could recover copper at less than US$2 a kilogram (2 pounds), which is less than a third of the international market price.

“The total value of all raw materials present in e-waste is estimated at approximately in 2016, which is more than the 2016 gross domestic product of most countries in the world,” says Cornelis Balde, a researcher with the United Nations University to Tokyo. 

Huge opportunities

Some fear that the potential profits from urban mining will lead to an upsurge in rogue operators, with escalating environmental and safety hazards. But more likely — just as poor regular miners soon get muscled out by big corporations when a new geological seam provides rich pickings — urban mines will soon be the preserve of the big operators.

Yet they have a ways to go. Zeng estimates only 20% of e-waste is currently handled by the “clean” sector of big companies using largely automated processes. About 40% ends up in places like Mandoli, in China’s notorious villages around Guiyu in Guangdong province, or in Agbogbloshie, a district in Accra, the capital of Ghana, which some say is currently the world’s largest e-waste dump. The remaining 40% is uncharted, often stored in drawers or attics or disposed of in landfills.

“There are huge business opportunities in e-waste recycling, especially in the big countries of e-waste generation,” says Zeng. So sending our e-waste to the back streets of India and China is not only ethically unacceptable, it is also a missed business opportunity at home.

Many ethically concerned consumers are conflicted about recycling e-waste. They applaud the virtues of recycling, but fear the stuff they are done with may end up polluting a Chinese village or poisoning Indian children. With increased awareness of the opportunities in urban mining, that dilemma could soon end.

Fred Pearce is an environmental and science journalist based in London. This post originally appeared at .

 

One Comment

  1. John Clark | | #1

    Nice read. I'm sure it would be possible to build a plant in the U.S. like what is used in Sweden although I suspect that would be exceedingly difficult.

Log in or create an account to post a comment.

Related

  • Guest Blogs

    Getting to Zero Waste

    One of the goals of a sustainable city is to effectively manage material flows into and out of the city. Garbage, or what environmental engineers call solid waste, presents some…

  • Guest Blogs

    Beyond Recycling

    Agbogbloshie, Ghana, is in the news again. International media — including The Guardian, Al Jazeera, and The Washington Post — have helped turn this place into an infamous example of…

  • Energy Solutions

    Safe Storage of Nuclear Waste

    In my seemingly endless desire to dive headfirst into controversy, let me return to the issue of nuclear waste storage — something I last wrote about in this column five…

  • Lakesideca News

    Sacramento Utility Unveils Revamped E-House Demo

    The E-House, an energy efficiency showcase that has long been a fixture in the lobby of Sacramento Municipal Utility District’s Customer Service Center, recently got a makeover. The model home,…

Community

Recent Questions and Replies

  • |
  • |
  • |
  • |